01 Cost & pricing
Formula-only vs. full development: which do you need?
Choose formula-only if you already have a co-packer, or you want to own the formula outright and take it anywhere. Choose full development if you don't have a manufacturer yet, can't hit co-packer minimums on your own, or want one partner from brief to pallet. At JOI Labs, Formula + Handoff typically runs $3,000–$5,000, and Formula + Supply starts at $5,000.
Both options start the same way: a brief, a formula, physical samples and a label. The real question is what happens after the formula is locked. Somebody has to buy ingredients, book a production line, hit a minimum run and keep you stocked. Formula-only means that somebody is you. Full development means it's us.
Side by side
| Formula + Handoff | Formula + Supply | |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Brands with a co-packer lined up | Brands without a manufacturer, or who want one partner |
| Formula, samples, nutrition, FDA label, allergens | Included | Included |
| Spec pack for your co-packer | Included | Included |
| Ingredient sourcing | You | Us |
| Production | Your co-packer | Our co-manufacturing network |
| Ongoing supply | You manage it | We keep you stocked |
| Formula ownership | Yours on final payment | Annual license, with buyout available |
| Price | $3,000–$5,000 | From $5,000 |
| Fee credit | None | Part credited toward your first PO when MOQ is met |
Minimum order requirements vary by category and pack-out. Third-party lab analysis and shelf-life testing are passed through at cost in both tiers, approved by you before anything is ordered.
Five questions that decide it
- Do you have a co-packer who has agreed to run your product? Not "talked to," agreed. If yes, formula-only is usually enough.
- Can you meet their minimum? Published minimums run from about 1,000–10,000 units for packaged food and 1,000–20,000 for beverages. Many shelf-stable runs land at 5,000–50,000 units per SKU, which can tie up a lot of cash in one run.
- Do you want to manage sourcing? Ingredient suppliers have their own minimums, lead times and paperwork. Somebody has to buy them, receive them and get them to the line.
- Do you need to own the formula outright now? If you plan to move between co-packers, or investors want the IP on your books, formula-only gives you full rights on final payment.
- How much do you want to spend upfront? Formula-only costs less at the start. Full development costs more upfront, but part of the fee comes back as a credit on your first PO when the project meets minimums.
What formula-only really gets you
A good formula-only project doesn't end with a recipe in an email. It ends with a spec pack your co-packer can actually run:
- The formula in weight percentages, not cups and spoons
- Process steps: order of addition, mixing, temperatures and critical control points where they apply
- Ingredient specs and the suppliers they were tested with
- Nutrition profile, FDA label and allergen statement
- Finished-product targets the co-packer can check each batch against
Without that pack, the co-packer has to reverse-engineer your product, and that's where "it tasted different at scale" comes from. It's also why industry budgets list spec documentation at $1,500–$3,000 as its own line. At JOI Labs it's included.
What full development adds
Formula + Supply picks up where the spec pack ends. We source the ingredients from our vetted supplier network, produce through our co-manufacturing network and keep finished goods coming on your schedule and at your volume. It's the same model behind JOI's own products: Squeezables, Scoopables and Pocketables, formulated, produced and sold by us.
The trade-off is ownership structure. While we produce it, the formula is licensed to you annually, and you can buy full rights at any time. That keeps the upfront cost lower and keeps one team accountable for the product, from the formula to the pallet.
Example: two founders, two answers
- Hot sauce brand, regional co-packer already booked
- Needs a shorter label and a spec pack
- Wants to own the formula outright
- Formula + Handoff, about $3,500
- Two powdered drink mix SKUs, no manufacturer yet
- Can't hit a typical co-packer minimum alone
- Wants one partner and no sourcing headaches
- Formula + Supply, from $5,000
Illustrative examples based on typical scopes. Not specific client projects.
Questions founders ask
Which option is cheaper?
Formula-only is cheaper upfront: Formula + Handoff typically runs $3,000–$5,000. Formula + Supply starts at $5,000, but part of that fee is credited toward your first purchase order when the project meets minimum order requirements. See how much food product development costs for the full breakdown.
Is the formula itself any different between the two?
No. Same lab, same ingredient library, same master formulators. The difference is where we stop: at the spec pack, or at finished goods on your schedule.
Who owns the formula in each option?
With Formula + Handoff, the formula and full documentation are yours on final payment. With Formula + Supply, we license the formula to you annually while we produce it, and you can buy full rights at any time.
Do I get physical samples either way?
Yes. Both include prototype samples, a nutrition profile, FDA label and allergen work. The first physical sample typically arrives 5–7 days after a confirmed brief, depending on ingredient availability. Here's the full timeline.
What if my co-packer's minimum is too high for me?
That's one of the most common reasons founders choose full development. Minimums vary by category and pack-out, so tell us your expected volume in the brief and we'll tell you what's realistic.
Not sure which one fits?
Send a brief. We'll recommend a tier, with a proposal, a timeline and a path to your first sample.